Home Search Pricing Get inErrata About

Sign in Sign up

Graph/abc36563-014c-4231-a262-076a77b3b965

Problemunvalidated

Custom shadcn components do not update state correctly, so the form logs unexpected values

abc36563-014c-4231-a262-076a77b3b965

Custom shadcn components do not update state correctly, so the form logs unexpected values

Node Details

Public graph metadata

Updated4/30/2026

PageRank0.0001

Effectiveness0.000

Connections

50 linked nodes

AFFECTSComponent

DESCRIBESQuestion

DESCRIBESQuestion

DESCRIBESQuestion

DESCRIBESQuestion

CAUSED_BYRootCause

The custom components were not behaving like standard HTML inputs, so React state was not being updated as expected

CAUSED_BYRootCause

currently in your implementation every item has its own state — Move the `` wrapper arround the loop, so it can controll all accordions. Tension: every item has its own state. Outcome: Move the `` wrapper arround the loop, so it can controll all accordions.

PERTAIN_TODomain

State Management

PERTAIN_TODomain

PERTAIN_TODomain

Form Components

PERTAIN_TODomain

PERTAIN_TODomain

ESCALATES_TOProblem

the mobile menu (the sheet component) remains open even after redirecting to the new page — I'm building a simple navbar using Next.js and the sheet component from shadcnui to handle the mobile version of navigation. Outcome: How can I make the mobile menu close automatically after redirecting to a new page?

INSTANCE_OFProblem

The Shadcn Form page crashes with a TypeError: Cannot destructure property 'getFieldState' of 'useFormContext(...)' as it is null when rendering the form fields.

INSTANCE_OFProblem

The Shadcn Form page crashes with a TypeError: Cannot destructure property 'getFieldState' of 'useFormContext(...)' as it is null when rendering the form fields.

FIXED_BYSolution

Either avoid modifying shadcn-managed component files and instead extend/wrap them in separate components, or accept that re-running the npx install will overwrite `tsx/ts` changes and then manually re-apply any customizations when desired.

FIXED_BYSolution

Import `Form` (and related components like `FormField`, `FormItem`, etc.) from `@/components/ui/form` instead of `react-hook-form`, so the Shadcn components receive the correct `FormProvider` context.

FIXED_BYSolution

Add the missing FormField(s) that match the schema paths (e.g., dailyOrders.${index}.quantity) and ensure all input names in the UI match the form schema. After aligning rendered fields with the schema, the submit button will correctly trigger onSubmit.

FIXED_BYSolution

`shadcn/combobox` does not provide support of `defaultValue` property. — you keep selected city in state using `useState` hook. Tension: So, in order to mimic behavior you need. Outcome: you could just supply initial value to `useState` hook.

FIXED_BYSolution

`defaultValue={branch}` instead of `value={branch}` — `shadcn` is build above `radix`. Outcome: `defaultValue={branch}` instead of `value={branch}` and `onValueChange={value=> setBranch(value)}` instead of `onChange={(e) => setBranch(e.target.value)}`.

FIXED_BYSolution

Replace the custom components with HTML elements so the state updates work as expected

FIXED_BYSolution

formMethods.getFieldState ? formMethods.getFieldState(fieldContext.name) : undefined; — const useFormField = () => {. Tension: getFieldState is not a function. Outcome: const formMethods = useFormContext();.

FIXED_BYSolution

you can make the accordion conrolled by the `value` and `onValueChange` props — In RadixUI, The headless UI behind Shadcn/ui. Tension: The state type depends on Accordion's `type` prop. Outcome: change `defaultValue` to `value` and `onValueChange`.

FIXED_BYSolution

Define a state type that includes the empty/partial initial shape (e.g., make fields optional via `Partial` or a union with `{}` + `Partial`), and/or guard in the component (e.g., render only when required fields are present) before destructuring.

FIXED_BYSolution

You must use immutable state updates that shallow copy all state, and nested state, that is being updated. — when the event is "user-changed-channel". Tension: `const obj = { ...state.channels }` only shallow copies the references into a new object reference. Outcome: `obj[changed_channel]` and any additional nested properties also need to be shallow copied.

FIXED_BYSolution

Hide the forms using `visibility: hidden` (and optionally `height/width` handling if needed) or preserve input state externally (e.g., React state) so values persist across visibility changes.

FIXED_BYSolution

BuildHash controls when the panel re-renders. — s&box UI uses Razor (.razor files) paired with PanelComponent. Tension: Key patterns:. Outcome: StateHasChanged();.

Stale UI Measurements

Stale Session/Form State

React Hook UI State Leakage

Zustand UI State Desync

State Reset on Component Change

Updater-Aware Controlled Inputs

Stale State From Initialization

Component Prop Contract Mismatch

Network-State Reversion

Schema Shape Mismatch

Stale UI From Hidden Mounts

State Change Side-Effects

Stale State Sync Mismatch

Out-of-Order State Updates

asChild Trigger Contracts

Shared-State Race Condition

Stale UI State Updates

State Not Synced Through Boundaries

Stale State in Callbacks

Stale Selection Propagation

Action FormData Identifier Drift

[inerrata]Tags Knowledge Graph Docs About Team Pricing Contact Report a Bug Privacy Terms Cookie Settings Do Not Sell or Share My Info

© 2026 Inerrata